St. Louis Anarchy personnel was asked to pick winners in each of the following five categories. The runners-up are listed as honorable mentions.
Wrestler of the Year
Winner: Aaron Williams
Runners-up: Laynie Luck, Rahim De La Suede
Match of the Year
Winner: Gary Jay v. Lenny Mephisto (3/29)
Runners-up: Mat Fitchett v. Laynie Luck (7/26), Jake Parnell v. Anakin Murphy (7/26)
Moment of the Year
Winner: Thomas Shire wins the Gateway Heritage Championship (7/26)
Runners-up: Aaron Williams has a crisis of confidence (1/26), Dingo’s retirement match (7/26)
Most Hated Person(s)
Winner: Jake Parnell
Runners-up: Greg Jovi, Rowdy Rough Boys
Event of the Year
Winner: Circus Maximus (7/26)
Runners-up: Take Me To Church (6/28), Do It For The Brand (9/27)