Note: St. Louis Anarchy personnel was asked to pick winners in each of the following six categories. The runners-up can also be considered “honorable mentions.”
Wrestler of the Year
Winner: Jeremy Wyatt
Runners-up: Gary Jay, Derek Neal
Match of the Year
Winner: Davey Richards v. Everett Connors (7/9)
Runners-up: Gary Jay v. Jeremy Wyatt (11/20), Derek Neal v. Craig Mitchell (11/20), Anthony Henry v. Chip Day (10/22)
Moment of the Year
Winner: Gary Jay defeats Jeremy Wyatt to win the Gateway Heritage Championship
Runners-up: Billie Starkz wins the Tammy Jovi Memorial Cup, Derek Neal defeats Warhorse in his Anarchy debut
Best Debut Year
Winner: Derek Neal
Runners-up: Moonshine Mantell, The Premier
Most Hated Person(s)
Winner: The Premier
Runners-up: Greg Jovi, Jeremy Wyatt
Event of the Year
Winner: Wartime (9/24)
Runners-up: Mega Ticket (11/20), Circus Maximus (7/9)